Best Alaska Cruise Princess or Holland America

Choosing between a Princess and Holland America Alaska cruise? Both offer stunning scenery, expert guides, and unforgettable wildlife encounters. This guide breaks down the key differences so you can pick the line that best fits your travel style, budget, and expectations.

Key Takeaways

• Princess Cruises excels in onboard entertainment and modern amenities: With larger ships and more dining options, Princess is ideal for families and travelers who enjoy a lively atmosphere.
• Holland America offers a more refined, traditional cruising experience: Known for its elegant ambiance and attentive service, it’s perfect for couples and mature travelers seeking a quieter journey.
• Both lines feature Glacier Bay National Park visits: A must-see highlight, but Holland America often includes more naturalist-led excursions and educational programs.
• Princess has more balcony cabins and family-friendly activities: Great for multi-generational trips, while Holland America focuses on comfort and relaxation.
• Itineraries vary slightly by season and ship: Princess often includes more port stops, while Holland America emphasizes longer stays in key destinations like Juneau and Ketchikan.
• Pricing is competitive, but value differs: Princess may offer more inclusive packages, while Holland America includes premium touches like complimentary wine with dinner.
• Customer service ratings are high for both: But Holland America consistently scores higher in guest satisfaction for personalized attention.

Introduction: Why an Alaska Cruise Should Be on Your Bucket List

Imagine standing on the deck of a ship, wrapped in a warm jacket, as towering glaciers calve into the icy waters below. Seals bask on floating ice, bald eagles soar overhead, and snow-capped mountains stretch endlessly into the horizon. This isn’t a scene from a movie—it’s the reality of an Alaska cruise, one of the most awe-inspiring travel experiences on Earth.

Alaska’s rugged coastline, pristine wilderness, and abundant wildlife make it a dream destination for nature lovers, adventure seekers, and anyone craving a break from the ordinary. And when it comes to exploring this vast, wild frontier, two cruise lines stand out: Princess Cruises and Holland America Line. Both have decades of experience sailing Alaskan waters, offering expertly curated itineraries that showcase the best of the Last Frontier. But which one is right for you?

In this detailed comparison, we’ll dive deep into what makes each line unique—from ship size and onboard amenities to shore excursions and service quality. Whether you’re planning a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a solo adventure, this guide will help you decide whether Princess or Holland America delivers the best Alaska cruise experience for your needs.

Princess Cruises: Big Ships, Big Experiences

Princess Cruises has long been a favorite among travelers seeking a balance of adventure and comfort. With a fleet of modern, mid-to-large-sized ships, Princess offers a vibrant, activity-packed experience that appeals to a wide range of passengers—especially families and younger travelers.

Ship Size and Onboard Atmosphere

Princess ships are generally larger than Holland America’s, with some vessels accommodating over 3,000 passengers. This means more space for entertainment venues, multiple dining options, and expansive public areas. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, with a focus on fun and engagement. Think Broadway-style shows, live music, cooking demonstrations, and even outdoor movie nights under the stars.

One standout feature is the Movies Under the Stars pool deck experience, where guests can watch films on a giant screen while lounging in heated pools or hot tubs. It’s a unique touch that adds a layer of magic to evenings at sea. Princess also offers the Discovery at Sea program, which partners with Discovery Channel to bring Alaskan wildlife and culture to life through interactive exhibits and themed activities.

Dining and Culinary Options

Foodies will appreciate Princess’s diverse dining scene. Most ships feature multiple specialty restaurants, including Sabatini’s Italian Trattoria, Crown Grill steakhouse, and the Salty Dog Gastropub. There’s also a strong emphasis on local Alaskan cuisine—think fresh king crab, wild salmon, and reindeer sausage—often featured in themed dinners or port-day menus.

The main dining rooms offer both traditional and flexible seating, and the buffet is well-stocked with international and regional options. For casual bites, the International Café and pizza bar are always popular. And don’t miss the afternoon tea service—a charming ritual that adds a touch of elegance to the day.

Cabin Comfort and Family-Friendly Features

Princess offers a wide range of staterooms, from interior cabins to luxurious suites. One advantage is the higher percentage of balcony rooms compared to many other lines—ideal for soaking in the stunning Alaskan views from the privacy of your own space. Families will love the connecting cabins and dedicated kids’ clubs, including the Camp Discovery program, which offers age-appropriate activities from arts and crafts to science experiments.

Teens aren’t left out either, with dedicated lounges and organized events like scavenger hunts and movie nights. The ships also feature multiple pools, water slides, and sports courts, making them a hit with younger travelers.

Shore Excursions and Itinerary Highlights

Princess Cruises typically offers 7-night roundtrip itineraries departing from Seattle or Vancouver, with stops in Juneau, Skagway, Ketchikan, and often Glacier Bay National Park. Their excursions are varied and plentiful, ranging from dog sledding on a glacier to whale-watching tours and gold panning in historic Skagway.

One popular option is the Mendenhall Glacier Helicopter Tour, which includes a landing on the ice—perfect for adventurous travelers. Princess also partners with local operators to offer cultural experiences, like Tlingit storytelling in Ketchikan or a visit to a salmon hatchery.

While the pace can feel brisk due to multiple port stops, the variety ensures there’s something for everyone. Just be prepared for crowds during peak season, especially at popular attractions like the Tracy Arm Fjord.

Holland America Line: Elegance, Tradition, and Intimate Exploration

If Princess is the life of the party, Holland America is the sophisticated guest who prefers a quiet conversation over a cocktail. Known for its refined atmosphere and classic cruising style, Holland America appeals to travelers who value comfort, tradition, and personalized service.

Ship Size and Onboard Ambiance

Holland America’s ships are smaller and more intimate, typically carrying between 1,400 and 2,100 passengers. This creates a cozier, more relaxed environment where staff often remember your name and preferences. The decor is elegant and timeless, with rich wood finishes, brass accents, and nautical touches that evoke a sense of old-world charm.

The pace is slower, the music is softer, and the focus is on relaxation and enrichment. You won’t find flashy water slides or loud nightclubs here—instead, expect live piano music in the lounges, art auctions, and enrichment lectures by naturalists and historians. The Explorations Central (EXC) program offers in-depth talks on Alaskan wildlife, geology, and indigenous cultures, often led by experts from organizations like the National Park Service.

Dining and Culinary Excellence

Holland America takes pride in its culinary offerings, with a strong emphasis on quality and presentation. The main dining room serves multi-course meals with a focus on seasonal and regional ingredients. One standout perk is the complimentary wine served with dinner—a small but meaningful touch that enhances the dining experience.

Specialty dining options include Pinnacle Grill, a premium steakhouse, and Canaletto, an Italian restaurant with a focus on fresh pasta and seafood. The Lido Market buffet is well-organized and offers a variety of international dishes, including Alaskan specialties like smoked salmon and halibut.

For a unique experience, try the “Dinner in the Pinnacle Grill” package, which includes a multi-course meal with wine pairings. It’s a splurge, but worth it for special occasions.

Cabin Comfort and Quiet Luxury

Staterooms on Holland America ships are designed for comfort and tranquility. While not as large as some luxury lines, they are well-appointed with plush bedding, marble bathrooms, and ample storage. Balcony cabins are available, though fewer in number than on Princess ships—so book early if a view is a priority.

The overall vibe is one of understated luxury. There are no kids’ clubs, which means the atmosphere remains peaceful and adult-oriented. This makes Holland America an excellent choice for couples, empty nesters, or anyone seeking a serene escape.

Shore Excursions and Educational Focus

Holland America’s excursions often emphasize education and cultural immersion. Their “Adventures Ashore” program includes expert-led tours like a guided hike through Tongass National Forest, a visit to a native Alaskan village, or a wildlife photography workshop.

One standout offering is the “Glacier Bay Naturalist Program,” where onboard naturalists provide live commentary as the ship navigates the park. This adds depth to the experience, helping passengers understand the ecosystem and conservation efforts in the region.

Itineraries are similar to Princess’s, with 7-night voyages from Seattle or Vancouver, visiting Juneau, Skagway, Ketchikan, and Glacier Bay. However, Holland America often spends more time in port, allowing for a more relaxed pace and deeper exploration.

Comparing Itineraries: Ports, Timing, and Glacier Bay Access

Both Princess and Holland America offer classic 7-night Alaska itineraries, but there are subtle differences in timing, port days, and access to key attractions.

Glacier Bay National Park: A Shared Highlight

One of the most coveted experiences on any Alaska cruise is a full-day navigation through Glacier Bay National Park. Both lines include this in their itineraries, but Holland America often has a slight edge in terms of naturalist presence and educational programming. Their ships typically spend the entire day in the park, with rangers boarding to provide commentary—something Princess also offers, but with less frequency.

Princess, on the other hand, may include additional scenic cruising in places like Tracy Arm or Endicott Arm, which feature dramatic fjords and active glaciers. This can be a bonus for travelers who want to see as much scenery as possible.

Port Stops and Shore Time

Juneau, Skagway, and Ketchikan are staples on both lines, but the length of stay and excursion options vary. Holland America often offers longer port days—sometimes up to 10 hours—giving passengers more time to explore at their own pace. Princess tends to have shorter stops, which can feel rushed if you’re eager to see everything.

For example, in Skagway, Holland America passengers might have time for a leisurely walk through the historic district, a visit to the Klondike Gold Rush National Historical Park, and a scenic train ride—all in one day. Princess guests might need to choose between the train and a glacier tour due to tighter scheduling.

Departure Cities and Seasonal Availability

Both lines operate primarily from Seattle and Vancouver, with some seasonal departures from San Francisco or Whittier (for one-way cruises ending in Seward). Peak season runs from May to September, with July and August being the busiest months.

If you prefer fewer crowds and lower prices, consider traveling in May or September. The weather is still pleasant, and you’ll have a better chance of spotting wildlife like bears and whales. Holland America often has more departures in the shoulder seasons, making it a good option for flexible travelers.

Service, Value, and Guest Experience

When it comes to service and overall value, both lines deliver high standards—but with different flavors.

Service Quality and Staff-to-Guest Ratio

Holland America consistently ranks higher in guest satisfaction surveys, particularly for personalized service. The staff-to-guest ratio is favorable, and crew members are known for their professionalism and warmth. Many guests report being addressed by name after just a few days onboard.

Princess also offers excellent service, but the larger ship size can sometimes make it feel less personal. That said, their crew is friendly and efficient, and the variety of staff—from entertainers to activity coordinators—adds to the vibrant atmosphere.

Pricing and What’s Included

Base fares are comparable, but what’s included can differ. Holland America includes wine with dinner, afternoon tea, and access to the EXC enrichment program at no extra cost. Princess may charge extra for specialty dining and some premium activities, though they often run promotions that bundle drinks or excursions.

For budget-conscious travelers, Princess sometimes offers better value with package deals. But if you appreciate small luxuries—like a glass of wine with dinner or a quiet lounge with a view—Holland America’s inclusions may feel more rewarding.

Accessibility and Special Needs

Both lines are committed to accessibility, with wheelchair-friendly cabins, elevators, and assistance programs. Holland America has a slight edge in terms of quiet spaces and low-stimulation environments, which can be beneficial for travelers with sensory sensitivities.

Which Line Is Right for You?

Choosing between Princess and Holland America ultimately comes down to your travel style and priorities.

If you’re traveling with kids, enjoy a lively atmosphere, and want a wide range of activities and dining options, Princess Cruises is likely the better fit. It’s ideal for families, first-time cruisers, and anyone who likes to stay busy.

If you prefer a quieter, more refined experience with a focus on education, relaxation, and personalized service, Holland America will feel like home. It’s perfect for couples, mature travelers, and those who appreciate the finer details of cruising.

And remember: both lines offer incredible access to Alaska’s natural wonders. Whether you’re marveling at a calving glacier or sipping coffee on your balcony as a whale breaches nearby, the real magic of an Alaska cruise lies in the destination—not just the ship.

Final Tips for Booking Your Alaska Cruise

No matter which line you choose, here are a few practical tips to make the most of your trip:

• Book early: Balcony cabins and popular excursions sell out fast, especially for peak season.
• Pack layers: Alaska’s weather can change quickly. Bring waterproof gear, warm layers, and sturdy shoes.
• Bring binoculars: Wildlife sightings are common, and a good pair of binoculars enhances the experience.
• Check visa requirements: If departing from Canada, ensure you have the proper documentation.
• Consider travel insurance: Weather delays and cancellations can happen, especially in remote areas.
• Download offline maps: Cell service is limited in many ports, so plan ahead for navigation.

An Alaska cruise with Princess or Holland America is more than a vacation—it’s a journey into one of the world’s last true wildernesses. With careful planning and the right cruise line, you’ll return home with memories that last a lifetime.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which cruise line is better for families: Princess or Holland America?

Princess Cruises is generally better for families due to its kids’ clubs, family-friendly activities, and higher number of connecting cabins. Holland America doesn’t offer kids’ programs, making it more suitable for adults.

Do both lines visit Glacier Bay National Park?

Yes, both Princess and Holland America include Glacier Bay in their standard 7-night itineraries, though Holland America often provides more naturalist-led commentary during the visit.

Is alcohol included in the cruise fare?

Holland America includes a glass of wine with dinner, while Princess typically charges extra for alcoholic beverages unless you purchase a drink package.

Which line has more balcony cabins?

Princess Cruises offers a higher percentage of balcony staterooms compared to Holland America, making it easier to secure a room with a view.

Are shore excursions the same on both lines?

Both offer similar excursions, but Holland America often emphasizes educational and cultural experiences, while Princess provides more adventure-focused options like helicopter tours and dog sledding.

Can I cruise one-way from Alaska to Vancouver?

Yes, both lines offer one-way cruises departing from Whittier or Seward and ending in Vancouver, typically in May and September. These are popular for travelers combining a cruise with a land tour.