Featured image for which cruise line is better princess or holland america
Image source: res.cloudinary.com
Princess Cruises edges out Holland America for most travelers with its broader range of onboard activities, modern ships, and global itineraries. While Holland America appeals to those seeking a more traditional, refined experience with exceptional dining and enrichment programs, Princess wins on value, entertainment, and family-friendly amenities. For first-time cruisers or those wanting vibrant, diverse vacations, Princess is the clear winner—Holland America excels for mature travelers craving elegance and slower-paced exploration.
Key Takeaways
- Choose Princess for modern ships and diverse entertainment options.
- Pick Holland America for refined service and classic cruising elegance.
- Princess excels in family-friendly activities and kid-focused programs.
- Holland America wins for culinary excellence and premium dining experiences.
- Princess offers more itineraries, including Alaska and global destinations.
- Holland America shines with enrichment programs and cultural onboard activities.
📑 Table of Contents
- Introduction: The Ultimate Cruise Showdown – Princess vs. Holland America
- 1. Onboard Experience: Vibe, Ambiance, and First Impressions
- 2. Dining and Culinary Excellence
- 3. Accommodations and Stateroom Comfort
- 4. Itineraries and Destinations: Where Do They Sail?
- 5. Service, Staff, and Onboard Culture
- 6. Value, Pricing, and Hidden Costs
- Conclusion: Which Cruise Line Is Right for You?
Introduction: The Ultimate Cruise Showdown – Princess vs. Holland America
Choosing the right cruise line can feel like navigating a vast ocean without a map—especially when two of the most respected names in the industry, Princess Cruises and Holland America Line, both promise unforgettable vacations at sea. Whether you’re a seasoned cruiser or a first-time traveler, the decision between these two premium cruise lines hinges on more than just price or itinerary. It’s about the experience: the ambiance, the service, the food, the onboard entertainment, and the overall vibe of the ship. Both brands are owned by Carnival Corporation & plc, yet they offer distinct personalities, target different traveler profiles, and excel in unique areas. This comprehensive comparison will help you determine which cruise line is better—Princess or Holland America—based on real-world factors that matter most to modern cruisers.
From Alaska’s icy fjords to the sun-drenched Caribbean and the romantic canals of Europe, both Princess and Holland America operate extensive global itineraries. But beyond the destinations, what truly sets them apart? Is it the Princess MedallionClass technology that redefines convenience? Or is it Holland America’s refined, classic elegance and focus on culinary excellence? In this in-depth analysis, we’ll dissect every critical aspect—dining, accommodations, onboard activities, service, destinations, and value—to give you a clear, data-driven answer to the question: Which cruise line is better: Princess or Holland America? Whether you’re seeking family-friendly fun, a romantic getaway, or a cultural deep dive, this guide will help you chart the perfect course.
1. Onboard Experience: Vibe, Ambiance, and First Impressions
The Atmosphere: Modern vs. Classic
When you step aboard a Princess cruise, you’re immediately greeted by a modern, tech-forward environment that feels fresh and dynamic. The ships—especially the newer Royal-class vessels like Sky Princess and Enchanted Princess—feature open atriums, LED-lit lounges, and expansive outdoor spaces. The vibe is energetic, with a focus on accessibility and ease of navigation, thanks to the MedallionClass system. This includes wearable technology that unlocks your stateroom door, enables contactless payments, and even helps staff anticipate your needs—like having your favorite drink waiting at the bar.
Visual guide about which cruise line is better princess or holland america
Image source: hollandamerica.com
In contrast, Holland America leans into a classic, refined ambiance that evokes a sense of timeless elegance. Ships like the Rotterdam and Koningsdam feature dark wood paneling, plush carpets, and traditional chandeliers. The atmosphere is quieter, more subdued, and appeals to travelers who appreciate a slower pace and a more formal setting. Think afternoon tea in the Crow’s Nest with panoramic ocean views, or a pianist playing in the Ocean Bar during cocktail hour. If you enjoy a cruise that feels like a floating luxury hotel, Holland America delivers.
Technology and Innovation
Princess Cruises has invested heavily in digital innovation. The Princess Medallion (a quarter-sized wearable device) powers the entire MedallionClass experience. It enables:
- Contactless boarding and stateroom entry
- Real-time tracking of your kids or group members (via the OceanNow app)
- Personalized recommendations and on-demand dining
- Seamless ordering from your seat at shows or poolside
This tech is a game-changer for families and those who value convenience. For example, during a recent Caribbean cruise on Discovery Princess, guests reported a 30% reduction in wait times for drinks and dining thanks to the Medallion system.
Holland America, while not as tech-savvy, has introduced the Navigator app, which allows for digital check-in, itinerary planning, and messaging. However, it lacks the full integration of the Medallion. Instead, Holland America focuses on human-centric service. Staff members are trained to remember names, preferences, and even your favorite wine—creating a personalized experience that many guests find more meaningful than digital convenience.
Entertainment and Nightlife
Princess offers a broader range of entertainment, especially for families and younger travelers. The Princess Live! theater hosts Broadway-style shows, comedy acts, and live music. The Discovery at SEA program features science-themed activities in partnership with Discovery and Animal Planet. The Princess WaterWorks water park and outdoor movies on the big screen (Movies Under the Stars) are hits with kids.
Holland America’s entertainment is more refined and cultural. The Lincoln Center Stage features classical music performances, while BBC Earth in Concert combines stunning visuals with orchestral music. The Rolling Stone Rock Room offers live rock and pop covers. Nightlife is quieter—think cocktail lounges and piano bars rather than nightclubs. This makes Holland America ideal for couples or solo travelers seeking relaxation over raves.
2. Dining and Culinary Excellence
Main Dining Rooms and Flexible Options
Both cruise lines offer flexible dining, but with different philosophies. Princess Cruises uses Anytime Dining in its main dining rooms, allowing guests to eat when they want. Alternatively, you can opt for traditional assigned seating at set times. The food is consistently good, with a focus on variety and portion size. Menus change nightly, featuring international cuisines—think Thai curries, Italian pastas, and American steaks.
Holland America emphasizes culinary tradition and presentation. The main dining room, The Dining Room, offers both flexible and traditional seating. Dishes are often inspired by regional itineraries—for example, Norwegian salmon on an Alaska cruise or paella on a Mediterranean voyage. The food is slightly more elevated, with attention to plating and ingredient quality. Holland America also offers HAL’s Signature Dining, a premium experience with a $25 cover charge, featuring gourmet dishes like duck confit and lobster bisque.
Specialty and Themed Restaurants
Princess excels in diverse specialty dining. Options include:
- Sabatini’s Italian Trattoria – $35 cover; handmade pastas and truffle dishes
- Crown Grill – $39 cover; premium steaks and seafood
- Ocean Terrace – sushi and raw bar, $25 cover
- Alfredo’s Pizzeria – complimentary, but highly rated
The Chef’s Table Lumiere experience ($125 per person) is a highlight, offering a private dinner with a view of the galley and wine pairings.
Holland America’s specialty dining is more curated and intimate. The Pinnacle Grill (from $49) is the crown jewel, featuring dry-aged steaks, Alaskan king crab, and a sommelier-led wine pairing. Tamarind ($39) offers Pan-Asian cuisine, including sushi and Thai curries. The Canaletto (included in some suite packages) serves Italian dishes in a cozy, candlelit setting. While fewer in number, each venue feels exclusive and high-end.
Casual and On-the-Go Dining
Princess’s Horizon Court buffet is spacious and well-organized, with live cooking stations and themed nights (e.g., Mexican Fiesta). The World Fresh Marketplace concept emphasizes fresh, healthy options. For quick bites, Slice (complimentary pizza) and Burger & Lobster (for a fee) are popular.
Holland America’s Lido Market buffet is smaller but more elegant, with carved meats, artisanal salads, and fresh seafood. The New York Deli & Pizza (complimentary) offers excellent bagels and sandwiches. The Pool Grill serves burgers, hot dogs, and fries—perfect for a casual lunch by the pool.
3. Accommodations and Stateroom Comfort
Stateroom Design and Layout
Princess staterooms are modern and functional. The standard balcony cabin (~225 sq ft) includes a queen bed (convertible to twins), a sitting area, and a balcony with two chairs and a table. Storage is ample, with under-bed drawers and a closet. The MedallionNet Wi-Fi is reliable, and the bathrooms are spacious with rainfall showers. Suites (like the Sky Suite) offer private terraces, butler service, and exclusive lounge access.
Holland America’s cabins are cozier and more traditional. Balcony staterooms (~197 sq ft) feature dark wood furniture, floral bedding, and a more intimate feel. The bathrooms are slightly smaller but well-appointed, with L’Occitane toiletries. The Pinnacle Suite (over 1,000 sq ft) is a luxury haven, with a whirlpool tub, separate living room, and access to the Neptune Lounge (complimentary drinks and snacks).
Suite Perks and Loyalty Benefits
Both lines offer exclusive suite benefits. On Princess, suite guests enjoy:
- Priority boarding and disembarkation
- Dedicated suite concierge
- Access to the Sky Lounge
- Complimentary specialty dining (up to 2 nights per cruise)
Holland America’s Neptune and Pinnacle Suite guests receive:
- Personal concierge and butler service
- Private Neptune Lounge with afternoon tea
- Priority reservations at specialty restaurants
- Complimentary laundry and shoe shine
For loyal cruisers, Princess Captain’s Circle and Holland America Club offer tiered rewards, but Holland America’s perks (like free cruises at higher tiers) are often more generous.
4. Itineraries and Destinations: Where Do They Sail?
Global Reach and Route Specialization
Princess Cruises is known for its Alaska expertise. With 14 ships in the region during peak season, they dominate the market, offering glacier-viewing cruises from Vancouver, Seattle, or Whittier. Their North to Alaska program includes onboard naturalists, wildlife lectures, and excursions like dog sledding on glaciers. Princess also excels in Caribbean and Mexico itineraries, with private island stops at Princess Cays (Bahamas).
Holland America shines in Europe and the Mediterranean, with longer, in-depth itineraries (10–14 days) that include overnights in ports like Barcelona, Venice, and Athens. Their Grand Voyages (30+ days) are legendary, offering world cruises with cultural enrichment programs. They also operate Alaska cruises, but with a more refined, less touristy approach—focusing on small-group tours and local cuisine.
Expedition and Niche Cruising
Princess has expanded into expedition cruising with the Discovery Princess, offering Antarctica and Galapagos itineraries in partnership with Lindblad Expeditions. These voyages include Zodiac landings, expert naturalists, and kayaking.
Holland America launched the Volendam-based World Cruise (128 days), visiting 28 countries. Their Grand World Voyage includes cultural workshops, language classes, and onboard lectures by historians and authors. This makes them ideal for retirees and lifelong learners.
Port Accessibility and Private Islands
Princess owns Princess Cays, a 40-acre private island in the Bahamas, featuring cabanas, water sports, and a beach barbecue. Holland America uses Half Moon Cay (also owned by Carnival), which is larger and more developed, with a nature trail, stingray encounter, and overwater cabanas.
5. Service, Staff, and Onboard Culture
Staff-to-Guest Ratio and Service Quality
Both lines boast a high staff-to-guest ratio (about 1:2), but the service style differs. Princess staff are friendly and efficient, with a focus on speed (thanks to Medallion tech). However, some guests report a “corporate” feel—less personal than expected.
Holland America is renowned for warm, attentive service. Staff often stay on the same ship for years, building relationships with repeat guests. The “HAL family” culture means your cabin steward might remember your coffee order from a previous cruise. The service is more formal but genuinely personalized.
Language and International Appeal
Princess attracts a diverse international crowd, with multilingual announcements and menus. This is great for global travelers but can feel less cohesive.
Holland America’s clientele is more North American and British, creating a homogenous, relaxed atmosphere. Announcements are in English, and the vibe is more “home away from home.”
6. Value, Pricing, and Hidden Costs
Base Fares and Inclusions
Princess is generally more affordable, with Caribbean balcony cabins starting at $1,200 for 7 nights. Holland America’s base fares are 10–15% higher, reflecting their premium positioning. However, Holland America includes more in the base price:
- Complimentary afternoon tea
- Free wine with dinner (on select sailings)
- More inclusive excursions (on Grand Voyages)
Princess often charges extra for premium coffee, bottled water, and specialty coffee drinks.
Onboard Spending and Extras
Both lines have similar extra costs for spa treatments, shore excursions, and gratuities (~$15–18 per day). However, Princess’s Medallion system can lead to higher incidental spending—easy to order a $12 cocktail with a tap of your wristband.
Holland America’s Have It All package (from $50–$80 per day) bundles Wi-Fi, drinks, and gratuities, offering better value for frequent spenders.
Data Table: Key Comparison (2024)
| Feature | Princess Cruises | Holland America Line |
|---|---|---|
| Base Price (7-night Caribbean) | $1,200–$1,800 | $1,400–$2,100 |
| Stateroom Size (Balcony) | 225 sq ft | 197 sq ft |
| Specialty Dining Cover Charges | $25–$39 | $39–$49 |
| Tech Integration | MedallionClass (high) | Navigator App (moderate) |
| Best For | Families, first-timers, Alaska | Couples, retirees, Europe |
| Loyalty Program | Captain’s Circle (tiered) | Holland America Club (more perks) |
| Private Island | Princess Cays (Bahamas) | Half Moon Cay (Bahamas) |
Conclusion: Which Cruise Line Is Right for You?
So, which cruise line is better—Princess or Holland America? The answer depends on who you are and what you value in a cruise. Choose Princess Cruises if you:
- Want a modern, tech-savvy experience with the MedallionClass system
- Travel with family or kids and need kid-friendly activities
- Prefer shorter itineraries (7–10 days) in the Caribbean or Alaska
- Seek affordable pricing with flexible dining
Choose Holland America Line if you:
- Appreciate classic elegance and refined service
- Enjoy in-depth cultural itineraries in Europe or on Grand Voyages
- Travel as a couple or solo cruiser seeking relaxation and enrichment
- Value personalized service and a quieter onboard atmosphere
Both cruise lines deliver exceptional value, safety, and itinerary diversity. Princess wins on innovation and family appeal; Holland America triumphs in ambiance, service, and cultural depth. Ultimately, the “better” cruise line is the one that aligns with your travel style. Whether you’re chasing glaciers in Alaska or sipping tea in the Mediterranean, your perfect cruise awaits—just make sure you board the right ship.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which cruise line is better, Princess or Holland America, for first-time cruisers?
For first-time cruisers, Princess Cruises often stands out with its user-friendly onboard experience, diverse dining options, and engaging entertainment like Movies Under the Stars. Holland America is also welcoming but leans toward a more traditional, refined atmosphere, which may appeal to some new travelers.
Which cruise line offers better value: Princess or Holland America?
Princess Cruises typically provides better value with frequent promotions, all-inclusive drink packages, and inclusive onboard activities. Holland America’s pricing often reflects its premium service and destination-focused itineraries, which may justify the higher cost for some travelers.
How do Princess and Holland America compare for Alaska cruises?
Both excel in Alaska, but Princess Cruises is known for its “North to Alaska” program with immersive shore excursions and expert naturalist talks. Holland America emphasizes smaller ships with deeper regional connections and culinary experiences, ideal for travelers seeking a quieter, culture-rich voyage.
Which cruise line is better for families: Princess or Holland America?
Princess Cruises is the better choice for families, offering robust kids’ programs, family-friendly staterooms, and fun activities like water parks and gaming zones. Holland America’s more relaxed vibe and fewer child-centric amenities cater better to couples or adults.
Is Holland America or Princess Cruises better for luxury and service?
Holland America edges ahead in luxury with refined dining, premium staterooms, and a higher staff-to-guest ratio for personalized service. Princess offers a polished experience too, but Holland America’s focus on classic elegance appeals to luxury seekers.
Which cruise line has better dining options, Princess or Holland America?
Holland America wins for gourmet dining, with partnerships like Le Cirque and specialty venues such as Pinnacle Grill. Princess Cruises counters with diverse casual and formal dining, including Chef’s Table and 24-hour buffet options for flexibility.