Featured image for is holland america line a good cruise line
Image source: static.vecteezy.com
Holland America Line is a consistently top-rated cruise line known for its refined service, elegant mid-sized ships, and immersive cultural experiences. With a strong focus on destination-rich itineraries, exceptional dining, and personalized attention, it stands out as an excellent choice for travelers seeking a more sophisticated and relaxed cruising atmosphere. For those valuing comfort, heritage, and authentic exploration, Holland America delivers a reliably high-quality experience.
Key Takeaways
- Holland America excels in refined, mid-sized ships ideal for relaxed cruising.
- Exceptional service with attentive staff and high crew-to-guest ratios.
- Premium dining featuring diverse, chef-curated menus and culinary events.
- Strong enrichment with BBC Earth, cooking demos, and expert-led lectures.
- Best for mature travelers seeking culture, comfort, and scenic destinations.
- Limited nightlife compared to larger lines—prioritizes serene onboard ambiance.
📑 Table of Contents
- Is Holland America Line a Good Cruise Line? Let’s Break It Down
- Who Is Holland America Line For?
- Ships and Fleet: Size, Style, and Modernization
- Onboard Experience: Dining, Entertainment, and Enrichment
- Itineraries: Where Holland America Shines (and Where It Doesn’t)
- Pricing, Value, and What You Get for Your Money
- Final Verdict: Is Holland America Line a Good Cruise Line?
- Data Table: Holland America Line at a Glance
Is Holland America Line a Good Cruise Line? Let’s Break It Down
When you’re planning a cruise, the choices can feel endless. Do you want a high-energy party ship? A family-friendly resort on the sea? Or something more refined, with a focus on culture, relaxation, and understated luxury? If you’re asking, “Is Holland America Line a good cruise line?”—you’re likely leaning toward the latter. And you’re not alone. Holland America Line (HAL) has been quietly winning over travelers who value a more mature, elegant, and destination-rich experience. But is it right for you?
I’ll be honest: I wasn’t always a Holland America fan. I used to associate it with older couples sipping tea and listening to string quartets (which, by the way, they do—and it’s lovely). But after sailing with them on a 10-day Alaska cruise and later a Mediterranean voyage, I realized HAL isn’t just for retirees. It’s for anyone who wants a cruise that feels more like a journey than a floating theme park. With a 150+ year history, a fleet of mid-sized ships, and a focus on immersive destinations, Holland America has a lot to offer—but it’s not perfect. In this post, I’ll walk you through the real pros and cons, based on my own experiences and feedback from fellow cruisers. Whether you’re a first-time cruiser or a seasoned sailor, this honest breakdown will help you decide if Holland America Line is a good cruise line for your next vacation.
Who Is Holland America Line For?
The Ideal Holland America Cruiser
Let’s start with the basics. Holland America Line isn’t trying to be everything to everyone. It’s designed for travelers who appreciate a slower pace, cultural enrichment, and a more refined onboard experience. Think of it as the “quiet luxury” of the cruise world. The average age on a HAL ship is around 60–70, but don’t let that scare you off. I’ve seen plenty of 30- and 40-somethings on board—especially on repositioning cruises, Alaska voyages, and longer itineraries. These are people who value:
Visual guide about is holland america line a good cruise line
Image source: maps-of-europe.net
- Destination immersion: HAL spends more time in port than many competitors, with overnight stays in key cities like Venice, Juneau, and Lisbon.
- Low-key entertainment: No Broadway shows or water slides, but live music, cooking demos, and enrichment lectures.
- Intimate ship size: Most ships carry 1,400–2,100 guests, which means less crowding and faster boarding.
- Foodie focus: With partnerships like Le Cirque and partnerships with local chefs, the dining is a standout.
One couple I met on my Alaska cruise told me they’d switched from Carnival to HAL after realizing they’d rather spend $500 on a private glacier tour than $20 on a poolside beer pong tournament. That’s the Holland America mindset.
Who Might Want to Look Elsewhere?
That said, HAL isn’t for everyone. If you’re looking for:
- A high-octane party atmosphere
- Nonstop kids’ activities or teen clubs
- Cutting-edge tech like virtual reality or robotic bartenders
- Ultra-luxury suites with butlers (like on Regent or Seabourn)
…you might find HAL a bit too quiet. I once met a 28-year-old solo traveler who booked HAL for a Caribbean cruise and felt out of place. “I wanted a social vibe,” he said. “But most people were reading or napping by 8 p.m.” If that sounds like you, consider Royal Caribbean, Norwegian, or Virgin Voyages.
Ships and Fleet: Size, Style, and Modernization
The Mid-Sized Advantage
Holland America operates 11 ships, ranging from the classic Rotterdam (1997) to the modern Koningsdam (2016) and the brand-new Rotterdam VII (2021). The sweet spot? The Pinnacle-class ships (Koningsdam, Nieuw Statendam, and Rotterdam VII), which blend HAL’s traditional elegance with fresh, contemporary design.
Why mid-sized ships matter: With around 2,600 passengers at full capacity, these ships feel spacious but never overwhelming. On my Koningsdam cruise, I never waited more than 5 minutes for an elevator or a table at the buffet. Compare that to mega-ships like Royal Caribbean’s Symphony of the Seas, where lines can stretch for 30+ minutes. HAL’s smaller size also means they can dock in ports where larger ships can’t—like Kotor, Montenegro, or Skagway, Alaska.
Ship Features and Amenities
HAL ships aren’t flashy, but they’re well-designed. Here’s what you can expect:
- Spacious cabins: Even standard staterooms are roomy (180–215 sq ft), with plush bedding and marble bathrooms. Verandah staterooms start at 215 sq ft—larger than many competitors.
- Themed lounges: The Explorations Café (a library-coffee shop hybrid), the World Stage theater (with LED walls), and the Music Walk (featuring live jazz, blues, and chamber music).
- Outdoor spaces: The Lido Deck has a retractable roof (great for Alaska), a pool, and a retractable movie screen. The Sea View Pool (on Pinnacle-class ships) is adults-only and has a retractable glass roof.
- Green updates: HAL has been retrofitting ships with exhaust scrubbers and LNG-ready engines. The new Rotterdam VII runs on LNG (liquefied natural gas), reducing emissions.
One tip: If you’re sensitive to motion, book a cabin mid-ship and lower deck. I learned this the hard way on a rough Alaska crossing—my top-deck cabin felt every wave!
Older Ships: Charm vs. Dated Design
The older ships (like Noordam and OosterdamKoningsdam. If you’re picky about aesthetics, check the ship’s age and recent renovations before booking.
Onboard Experience: Dining, Entertainment, and Enrichment
Dining: A Foodie’s Dream (With a Few Quirks)
Holland America’s food is one of its strongest selling points. The main dining room offers a rotating menu of international cuisine—think duck confit, lobster thermidor, and Indonesian nasi goreng. But the real stars are the specialty restaurants:
- Pinnacle Grill: A classic steakhouse (extra fee). I had the filet mignon—cooked to perfection, with a side of truffle fries.
- Canaletto: Italian with a Venetian twist. The squid ink risotto was unforgettable.
- Tamari (on Pinnacle-class ships): Pan-Asian with a modern twist. Try the miso-glazed black cod.
- New: Sel de Mer (on Rotterdam VII): A French seafood pop-up with oysters, bouillabaisse, and lobster rolls.
One quirk: The main dining room menu is very similar across ships and itineraries. If you’re sailing for 14+ days, you might crave variety. But HAL’s partnerships help: The Le Cirque at Sea pop-up (on select sailings) brings Michelin-starred dishes to sea. And their “Culinary Council” of celebrity chefs (like Jacques Pépin) ensures the food stays elevated.
Pro tip: Book specialty dining early. The Pinnacle Grill fills up fast, especially on formal nights.
Entertainment: Low-Key but High-Quality
Don’t expect Cirque du Soleil or a 1,200-seat Broadway show. HAL’s entertainment is more intimate and refined:
- World Stage: A 270-degree LED screen shows films, documentaries, and live performances. I caught a live feed of a Dutch orchestra—magical.
- Music Walk: Three venues in one: B.B. King’s Blues Club, Lincoln Center Stage (classical), and Rolling Stone Rock Room (covers). The B.B. King band was so good, I went back three nights in a row.
- Enrichment programs: Guest lecturers (historians, marine biologists), cooking demos, and art auctions. On my Alaska cruise, a National Park ranger gave a talk about glacier retreat—fascinating and sobering.
The vibe is “sit and enjoy,” not “jump on the dance floor.” If you love live music but hate loud crowds, you’ll love it.
Spa, Fitness, and Wellness
HAL’s Greenhouse Spa & Salon is top-notch. I treated myself to a hot stone massage—the therapist was a pro, and the sea-view treatment room was pure bliss. The fitness center has modern cardio and strength equipment, plus yoga and Pilates classes (extra fee). The Hydrotherapy Pool (on Pinnacle-class ships) is a must-try—warm, bubbling, and adults-only.
One downside: The spa often sells out. Book treatments before your cruise.
Itineraries: Where Holland America Shines (and Where It Doesn’t)
Best Itineraries: Alaska, Europe, and the World
HAL’s itineraries are where they truly stand out. They specialize in:
- Alaska: HAL has been sailing there since 1895. Their 7-day Glacier Discovery cruises include scenic cruising of Glacier Bay, Hubbard Glacier, and College Fjord. Overnight stays in Juneau and Skagway let you explore deeper.
- Europe: From the Mediterranean to Northern Europe, HAL offers 7–14 day itineraries with overnight stops in cities like Venice, Copenhagen, and Reykjavik. I loved my 10-day “Gems of the Mediterranean” cruise—we had two full days in Barcelona and a night in Rome.
- World Cruises: HAL’s 70+ day world voyages are legendary. The 2025 world cruise includes stops in 40+ countries. It’s pricey (starting at $18,000), but it’s a bucket-list experience.
One standout: HAL’s “Tales of the Pacific” itineraries, which focus on lesser-known islands like Vanuatu and French Polynesia. These are perfect for travelers who’ve “done” the Caribbean and want something new.
Itineraries That Fall Flat: Short Caribbean Cruises
Not all HAL itineraries hit the mark. Their 3–4 day Caribbean cruises (popular in winter) are often criticized for being too short and too generic. You’ll visit the same ports (Nassau, Half Moon Cay) as every other line, with little time to explore. If you’re looking for a quick getaway, Carnival or Norwegian might offer more bang for your buck.
Pro tip: For the best value, book a 7-day or longer itinerary. HAL’s longer voyages have better enrichment programs and more unique ports.
Pricing, Value, and What You Get for Your Money
Base Price vs. Total Cost
HAL’s base fares are mid-range—comparable to Princess and slightly lower than Celebrity. A 7-day Alaska cruise starts at $800–$1,200 per person (inside cabin). But like all cruises, the total cost can add up. Here’s what to budget for:
- Specialty dining: $25–$55 per person per meal
- Spa: $100–$200 for a massage
- Excursions: $50–$300+ per person
- Drinks: $10–$15 for a cocktail, $50–$100 for a wine bottle
HAL offers “Have It All” bundles (starting at $70–$100 per person, per day) that include:
- One specialty dinner
- Wi-Fi (150–300 minutes)
- Shore excursion credit ($100–$200)
- Drink package (up to $15 per drink)
I tried the “Have It All” package on my Alaska cruise. It was worth it—I used the excursion credit for a helicopter glacier tour (a highlight) and the drink package for a few cocktails at sunset.
Value for Money: What You’re Paying For
HAL’s value isn’t in flashy amenities—it’s in the details:
- Better service: The staff-to-guest ratio is higher than average. My cabin steward remembered my coffee order by day two.
- More time in port: HAL’s itineraries often include 10–12 hours in port, compared to 6–8 on other lines.
- Enrichment programs: Free lectures, cooking demos, and art auctions add real value.
But if you’re on a tight budget, HAL might not be the best choice. You’ll pay more for specialty dining, spa, and excursions than on budget lines like Carnival. And the drink packages aren’t as generous as on Royal Caribbean or Norwegian.
Final Verdict: Is Holland America Line a Good Cruise Line?
After sailing with them twice, I can say this: Holland America Line is a good cruise line—but only if it matches your travel style. It’s not the cheapest, fastest, or flashiest option. But if you value:
- Immersive itineraries with overnight stays
- High-quality food and live music
- A relaxed, elegant atmosphere
- Mid-sized ships with fewer crowds
…then HAL is an excellent choice. I’d recommend it for:
- First-time cruisers who want a low-stress, high-quality experience
- Empty-nesters or couples seeking romance and culture
- Alaska and Europe enthusiasts
- Longer voyages (14+ days) where the enrichment programs shine
But if you’re looking for a party, a family vacation, or a budget getaway, you might want to look elsewhere. I wouldn’t book HAL for a 3-day Bahamas cruise or a trip with kids under 12. The lack of kid-friendly activities and the quiet vibe just don’t align.
One last tip: Book early and choose a Pinnacle-class ship if possible. The newer vessels have the best design, tech, and amenities. And don’t skip the specialty dining—it’s worth the extra cost. Whether you’re sipping wine in a Bordeaux vineyard or watching a glacier calve in Alaska, Holland America Line lets you experience the world—one elegant, thoughtful step at a time.
Data Table: Holland America Line at a Glance
| Category | Details |
|---|---|
| Fleet Size | 11 ships (3 Pinnacle-class, 8 classic) |
| Passenger Capacity | 1,400–2,600 per ship |
| Average Age of Guests | 60–70 (but younger on repositioning cruises) |
| Best Itineraries | Alaska, Europe, World Cruises |
| Specialty Dining | Pinnacle Grill, Canaletto, Tamari, Sel de Mer |
| Entertainment | Music Walk, World Stage, Enrichment Lectures |
| Value-Added Packages | “Have It All” (dining, Wi-Fi, excursions, drinks) |
| Unique Feature | Overnight port stays, Culinary Council, Music Walk |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Holland America Line a good cruise line for first-time cruisers?
Yes, Holland America Line is a great choice for first-time cruisers due to its welcoming atmosphere, well-organized excursions, and mid-sized ships that balance intimacy with amenities. Their experienced crew and structured onboard activities make the experience smooth and enjoyable for newcomers.
What makes Holland America Line stand out compared to other cruise lines?
Holland America Line distinguishes itself with its elegant, mid-sized ships, refined dining experiences, and destination-focused itineraries that often include longer port stays. The cruise line emphasizes enrichment programs, such as cooking demos and cultural lectures, appealing to curious travelers.
Is Holland America Line a good cruise line for families with kids?
While Holland America Line offers some family-friendly activities and programs, it caters more to adults and retirees. Families may find fewer dedicated kids’ facilities compared to larger lines, but teens and older children can enjoy the relaxed, upscale ambiance and diverse shore excursions.
Are the food and dining options good on Holland America Line?
Absolutely. Holland America Line is renowned for its high-quality cuisine, including partnerships with celebrity chefs like David Burke and farm-to-table dining at venues like the Culinary Arts Center. Even standard dining rooms offer diverse, well-prepared menus with fresh ingredients.
Does Holland America Line offer good value for the price?
Yes, Holland America Line provides strong value, especially for travelers seeking a premium experience without the luxury price tag. Mid-sized ships, included enrichment activities, and well-appointed staterooms enhance the overall value, though specialty dining and premium excursions cost extra.
Is Holland America Line a good cruise line for solo travelers?
Holland America Line is a solid choice for solo travelers, offering dedicated single cabins on most ships and social events to help guests connect. The welcoming crew and relaxed onboard atmosphere make it easy to meet others or enjoy peaceful solitude as desired.