How Does MSC Cruise Line Stack Up Against the Competition

Picture this: You’re standing on a sunlit deck, a gentle sea breeze in your hair, as the Mediterranean coastline glides past. The ship is sleek, modern, and buzzing with energy. You’re not on a luxury liner or a mega-resort at sea—you’re on an MSC Cruise Line vessel, one of the fastest-growing names in the cruise industry. With over 20 ships in its fleet and more on the way, MSC Cruises has become a serious contender in the global cruise market. But how does it really compare to the giants like Royal Caribbean, Carnival, and Norwegian Cruise Line?

That’s the million-dollar question—especially if you’re trying to pick the perfect vacation without blowing your budget or sacrificing comfort. Whether you’re a first-time cruiser or a seasoned sailor, understanding how MSC stacks up in terms of value, service, dining, entertainment, and overall experience is key. In this deep dive, we’ll explore every facet of MSC Cruises, from its family-friendly features to its growing luxury offerings, and compare it side-by-side with its biggest competitors. No fluff, no bias—just honest insights to help you decide if MSC is the right fit for your next adventure.

Value and Pricing: Is MSC a Budget-Friendly Cruise Option?

Low Base Fares with Smart Upselling

One of the first things travelers notice about MSC Cruises is its competitive base pricing. On average, MSC offers some of the lowest starting fares in the industry. For example, a 7-night Mediterranean cruise can begin at $499 per person, while similar itineraries on Royal Caribbean or Norwegian might start at $799 or higher. That’s a significant saving, especially for families or budget-conscious travelers.

Visual guide about how does msc cruise line stack up

Image source: backroadplanet.com

But here’s the catch: MSC’s pricing model is built on à la carte add-ons. While your cabin might be cheap, extras like drink packages, specialty dining, shore excursions, and even Wi-Fi come at a premium. This “low base, high upsell” approach is common across the industry, but MSC leans into it more than most. Think of it like buying a smartphone with a low sticker price—but you’ll pay extra for the case, screen protector, and cloud storage.

Tip: If you’re booking with MSC, consider purchasing a MSC Voyagers Club membership. Even at the basic “Classic” level, it gives you early booking access, onboard credit, and discounts on drinks and excursions. It’s a smart way to offset some of those add-on costs.

All-Inclusive Packages: Worth the Upgrade?

MSC offers several bundled packages, including the Beverage Package, Premium Dining, and All-Inclusive Experience. The All-Inclusive package, which includes drinks, Wi-Fi, and gratuities, starts around $129 per person, per week—much cheaper than buying those services separately.

For example, on a 7-night cruise, buying drinks, Wi-Fi, and tips individually could cost $400+ per person. The All-Inclusive package brings that down to around $200–$300, depending on the ship and itinerary. That’s a solid deal if you plan to drink cocktails by the pool or stay connected during your trip.

But—and this is a big “but”—the drink package has restrictions. It covers house wines, select cocktails, and non-alcoholic beverages, but excludes premium spirits, champagne, and room service drinks. If you’re a wine connoisseur or love a good martini, you might still end up paying extra.

Pro tip: Compare the All-Inclusive package cost against your expected usage. If you only want Wi-Fi and a few drinks, it might be cheaper to buy those a la carte.

How MSC Compares on Value

Let’s compare MSC to two major competitors:

Royal Caribbean: Higher base fares (often 20–30% more), but more inclusive amenities (e.g., more free dining options, larger pools, better Wi-Fi). Royal Caribbean’s “Deluxe Beverage Package” is pricier but covers top-shelf liquor and room service.

< Carnival Cruise Line: Similar low base prices, but Carnival includes more in the base fare (like soft drinks and basic Wi-Fi). Carnival’s “Cheers!” drink package is more generous than MSC’s, covering premium drinks at a lower cost.

Norwegian Cruise Line (NCL): NCL’s “Free at Sea” promotion often includes free drink packages, Wi-Fi, and shore excursion credits—making it a strong value competitor, especially for first-time cruisers.

So, MSC wins on initial price, but you need to be savvy about add-ons. If you’re disciplined about spending, MSC can be a great deal. If you want fewer surprises, NCL or Carnival might offer better peace of mind.

Dining Experience: From Buffet to Gourmet

Complimentary Dining: Quantity Over Quality?

MSC Cruises offers a mix of dining venues, including the main dining room (with assigned or flexible seating), a 24-hour buffet, and several casual spots like pizza bars and grill stations. The buffet, known as the Buffet La Pergola, is large and well-stocked, with rotating themes (e.g., Italian, Asian, BBQ nights).

But here’s the reality: the food quality in the complimentary areas is hit-or-miss. While the variety is impressive, some dishes lack flavor, and the presentation can feel mass-produced. On a recent MSC Seaside cruise, I found the buffet lasagna lukewarm and the salad bar underwhelming. That said, the pizza—cooked fresh in a wood-fired oven—was a standout. And the grill section offered surprisingly good burgers and hot dogs.

The main dining room is better, with a rotating menu that includes international dishes. But service can be inconsistent. On one night, our waiter was attentive and charming; the next, we waited 20 minutes just to order water.

Specialty Dining: A Step Up

MSC’s specialty restaurants are where the cruise line truly shines. These include:

Eataly Steakhouse: A partnership with the famous Italian food brand. Think dry-aged steaks, truffle pasta, and an extensive wine list. Reservations recommended.
Ocean Cay: A seafood-focused restaurant with fresh oysters, grilled fish, and ceviche. The ocean views are stunning.
Butcher’s Cut: A modern steakhouse with premium cuts and craft cocktails.

These restaurants are high-quality, with attentive service and excellent food. The Eataly Steakhouse, in particular, rivals land-based fine dining spots. But—surprise, surprise—they’re not cheap. Expect to pay $40–$60 per person, not including drinks.

Compared to competitors:

Royal Caribbean: Offers more specialty dining options (e.g., Wonderland, Chops Grille, Jamie’s Italian), and the quality is consistently high. Many are included in premium packages.
NCL: Has a wide range of specialty restaurants, and their “Free at Sea” deal often includes one free reservation.
Carnival: More casual, with fun spots like Guy’s Burger Joint and BlueIguana Cantina. Less gourmet, but great for families.

Room Service and Dietary Needs

MSC’s room service menu is limited—think sandwiches, salads, and basic entrees. It’s free during certain hours but costs $7.95 outside of them. The quality is average, and delivery can be slow (up to 45 minutes).

For dietary restrictions, MSC does a decent job. You can request vegetarian, gluten-free, or diabetic meals in advance, and the staff tries to accommodate. But on a recent cruise, my gluten-free pizza arrived with a regular crust—so double-check when ordering.

Tip: Use the MSC app to pre-order room service or book specialty dining. It saves time and avoids long lines.

Ship Design and Amenities: Modern, But Is It Comfortable?

Ship Size and Layout

MSC’s newer ships—like the MSC Seaside, MSC Meraviglia, and MSC World Europa—are massive, with 2,000+ cabins and 18+ decks. The World Europa, launched in 2022, is the largest ship in the fleet at 215,863 GT, with 2,626 cabins and a capacity of over 6,700 guests.

These ships are designed with European flair—think sleek glass atriums, marble floors, and open-air promenades. The Seaside class, for example, features a “beach pool” with a retractable roof and a 1,100-foot-long promenade with ocean views on both sides.

But size comes with trade-offs. On a busy cruise, the ship can feel crowded, especially at the pool deck and buffet. The layout is logical but can be confusing at first—some elevators only go to certain decks, and signage isn’t always clear.

Onboard Activities and Entertainment

MSC’s entertainment lineup is strong, with Broadway-style shows, live music, and themed parties. The MSC World Europa even has a 1,200-seat theater and a digital art gallery.

But here’s the catch: many shows are in Italian or English with subtitles, which can be a turn-off for non-Italian speakers. On one cruise, I attended a Cirque du Soleil-style performance that was visually stunning—but the narration was entirely in Italian. The subtitles helped, but it broke the immersion.

Other amenities include:

Water parks: Great for kids, with slides and splash zones. The Seaside has a 1,000-foot-long water slide.
Casino: Large and modern, with slots, table games, and a poker room. Open to guests 18+.
Spa and fitness: The Aurea Spa offers massages, facials, and a thermal suite. The gym is well-equipped but often crowded.

How It Compares to Competitors

Let’s break it down:

Royal Caribbean: Bigger ships (e.g., Icon of the Seas at 250,800 GT), more high-tech amenities (e.g., surf simulators, skydiving), and English-only entertainment. Better for families with teens.
NCL: “Freestyle Cruising” means no fixed dining times and more casual vibes. Ships are slightly smaller, with fewer crowds.
Carnival: Focuses on fun—think comedy clubs, karaoke, and deck parties. Less luxury, more energy.

MSC’s ships are beautiful and modern, but they can feel overwhelming. If you prefer a more relaxed, intimate experience, NCL or a smaller Carnival ship might be better.

Service and Guest Experience: The Human Touch

Staffing and Language

MSC is a Swiss-based company, but its staff come from all over the world—India, the Philippines, Italy, and Eastern Europe. This means service is generally good, but language can be a barrier. Most staff speak English, but accents and vocabulary can make communication tricky.

On one cruise, I asked a bartender for a mojito. He nodded and brought me a rum and coke. When I explained, he smiled and said, “Ah, mint? I try again.” He did—and it was perfect. But it took three tries.

The crew is friendly and hardworking, but the service pace can be slow. At peak times (e.g., dinner in the main dining room), wait times for drinks or food can stretch to 30 minutes.

Gratuities and Tipping Culture

MSC automatically adds $12–$15 per person, per day to your onboard account for gratuities. You can adjust this amount or remove it, but most guests leave it as-is. This is in line with industry standards (Royal Caribbean: $14.50, Carnival: $13.50).

But here’s a tip: if you receive exceptional service, tip extra in cash. The staff appreciates it, and it’s a nice way to show gratitude.

Family-Friendly Features

MSC is one of the most family-friendly cruise lines. Kids sail free on many sailings (ages 0–11), and the youth program is excellent. The Doremi Club offers age-specific activities, from arts and crafts to video games and sports.

The family cabins are spacious, with bunk beds, pull-out sofas, and extra storage. Some ships even have family suites with two bathrooms and separate living areas.

Compared to Royal Caribbean (with its Adventure Ocean program) and NCL (with its Splash Academy), MSC holds its own. But Royal Caribbean’s kids’ zones are more tech-heavy, with VR games and science labs.

Sustainability and Innovation: The Future of MSC

Eco-Friendly Initiatives

MSC has made big investments in sustainability. The MSC World Europa runs on LNG (liquefied natural gas), which reduces CO2 emissions by 25% and sulfur oxides by 99%. The ship also has advanced wastewater treatment and energy-efficient lighting.

MSC plans to launch its first hydrogen-powered cruise ship by 2025—a major step toward zero-emission cruising.

Digital Innovation

The MSC for Me app is a standout feature. It lets you book excursions, check schedules, order room service, and even track your ship’s location. The app also has a “digital concierge” that answers questions in real time.

Onboard, facial recognition speeds up embarkation, and wearable wristbands (like Carnival’s “Ocean Medallion”) are being tested for payments and room access.

How It Stacks Up

MSC is ahead of most competitors in sustainability, but Royal Caribbean is catching up with its “Destination Net Zero” plan. In digital tech, MSC’s app is on par with NCL’s “Haven” app and Carnival’s “Ocean Compass.”

Conclusion: Is MSC the Right Choice for You?

So, how does MSC Cruise Line stack up? The answer depends on what you value most.

If you’re looking for low upfront costs and don’t mind paying extra for drinks, dining, and Wi-Fi, MSC is a fantastic choice. Its ships are stunning, the specialty dining is excellent, and the family perks are hard to beat. The sustainability efforts and tech innovations also make it a forward-thinking option.

But if you want more inclusive pricing, faster service, or English-only entertainment, Royal Caribbean or NCL might be better. Carnival wins for pure fun and affordability, especially for families on a budget.

Ultimately, MSC is a solid mid-tier option—not the cheapest, not the most luxurious, but a great balance of value, comfort, and style. It’s ideal for:

Families with young kids (thanks to free sailing and great youth programs)
Travelers who want a modern, stylish ship without breaking the bank
Eco-conscious cruisers who value sustainable practices
Adventurers who don’t mind a little language barrier for the sake of a unique experience

Just remember: read the fine print on add-ons, book specialty dining early, and use the app to stay organized. With a little planning, an MSC cruise can be a memorable, affordable, and downright enjoyable vacation.

So, is MSC the right fit for your next cruise? If you’re ready for a blend of European elegance, smart savings, and family fun, the answer might just be yes.

Comparison Data Table

Feature	MSC Cruises	Royal Caribbean	Carnival Cruise Line	Norwegian Cruise Line
Starting Fare (7-night Med)	$499	$799	$549	$699
Kids Sail Free	Yes (ages 0–11)	Limited promotions	Yes (ages 2–11)	Yes (ages 0–12)
Drink Package Cost	$69–$89/day	$89–$138/day	$59–$69/day	$89–$109/day
Specialty Dining (Avg. Cost)	$40–$60	$35–$70	$20–$50	$35–$65
Wi-Fi (Per Day)	$14.99–$29.99	$24.99–$34.99	$15.95–$21.95	$24.99–$34.99
Gratuities (Per Day)	$12–$15	$14.50–$16.50	$13.50–$15.50	$14.50–$16.50
Largest Ship (GT)	215,863 (MSC World Europa)	250,800 (Icon of the Seas)	180,000 (Mardi Gras)	169,000 (Norwegian Encore)
Sustainability	LNG-powered ships, hydrogen plans	“Destination Net Zero” by 2050	LNG and hybrid ships	LNG and solar panels

Use this table as a quick reference when comparing MSC to the competition. The right choice depends on your priorities—but now, you’re armed with the facts to make an informed decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does MSC Cruise Line stack up in terms of affordability compared to other major cruise lines?

MSC Cruise Line is known for offering competitive pricing, often undercutting rivals like Royal Caribbean and Norwegian Cruise Line, especially on newer ships in the Mediterranean and Caribbean. Their “Kids Sail Free” promotions and all-inclusive packages further enhance value for budget-conscious travelers.

What makes MSC Cruise Line unique in the luxury cruise market?

MSC stands out with its MSC Yacht Club, a ship-within-a-ship concept offering exclusive suites, private lounges, and 24/7 butler service—rivaling luxury lines like Regent Seven Seas. Their partnerships with Cirque du Soleil and Jean-Philippe Maury also elevate onboard entertainment.

How does MSC Cruise Line stack up for family-friendly vacations?

MSC excels with dedicated kids’ clubs, LEGO-themed activities, and splash parks on most ships. Their flexible dining options and family staterooms make them a strong contender against Carnival and Disney Cruise Line for multigenerational trips.

Are MSC Cruise Line’s newer ships as modern as those from competitors?

Absolutely. The MSC World Europa and Meraviglia-Plus ships feature cutting-edge tech like AI-powered navigation, hybrid power systems, and the industry’s first humanoid robot bartender—on par with Royal Caribbean’s Quantum-class innovations.

How does MSC Cruise Line’s dining compare to other premium cruise lines?

MSC offers diverse options, from casual buffets to specialty venues like Butcher’s Cut steakhouse and Eataly Italian restaurants. While not as extensive as Celebrity Cruises, their partnerships with Michelin-starred chefs add gourmet appeal.

Is MSC Cruise Line environmentally sustainable compared to competitors?

MSC leads with LNG-powered ships, advanced wastewater treatment, and a 2050 net-zero emissions pledge. Their sustainability initiatives match or exceed those of Norwegian Cruise Line and Princess Cruises, earning recognition from Green Marine certification.

Key Takeaways

📑 Table of Contents